Tag Archives: coin dealer

A Collector’s Guide to Choosing the Ideal Coin Store

How to Find the Perfect Coin Shop for Your Numismatic Needs

Coin collecting, a captivating pastime, has intrigued and delighted people of all ages for generations. As an enthusiastic collector, whether you’re just starting or already possess an extensive collection, it’s essential to locate the perfect coin shop for buying, selling, or trading your precious pieces. In this article, we’ll walk you through the process of finding the ideal coin shop nearby, considering key factors like reputation, expertise, and convenience.

Reputation and Reviews

When searching for a coin shop, a great place to start is by looking for shops with a solid reputation. Online reviews and testimonials can provide valuable insight into the experiences of other collectors with a particular coin shop. Seek out reviews on platforms like Google, Yelp, and social media to gather a well-rounded understanding of the shop’s customer service, pricing, and overall satisfaction.

Expertise and Experience

Another critical factor to consider is the expertise and experience of the coin shop’s staff. A knowledgeable and experienced staff will be able to offer you valuable advice, accurately grade and authenticate coins, and provide guidance on current market trends. Look for shops with professional affiliations, such as membership in the American Numismatic Association or Professional Numismatists Guild. These affiliations indicate a commitment to ethical and professional practices.


A coin shop’s inventory should cater to a wide range of interests, offering a diverse selection of coins, bullion, and collectibles. Additionally, a good coin shop should provide essential services such as coin grading, appraisals, and authentication. Ensure that the shop can cater to your specific collecting interests, whether it be ancient coins, commemorative coins, or modern bullion.

Pricing and Transparency

Transparent pricing is essential when choosing the right coin shop. A trustworthy dealer should have a well-defined pricing structure that is based on the coin’s rarity, condition, and market demand. Inquire about the shop’s buy and sell prices, and compare them with online resources like the Coin Dealer Newsletter (CDN) or the Professional Coin Grading Service (PCGS) Price Guide, and even CoinTrackers.com. This comparison will help you determine if their pricing is fair and competitive.

Location and Accessibility

While it may be tempting to choose a coin shop that is closest to you, it is important to consider the quality of the shop over its proximity. In some cases, it may be worth driving a little further to find a reliable coin dealer. Be prepared to explore multiple shops in your area or even in neighboring cities to find the right fit.

Building Relationships

Establishing a good rapport with the staff at your chosen coin shop can lead to a mutually beneficial relationship. A strong connection with your coin dealer can lead to preferential treatment, such as being notified of new inventory arrivals, receiving personalized recommendations, and possibly even gaining access to better deals.

Selecting the right coin shop is an essential step in your coin collecting journey. By considering factors such as reputation, expertise, inventory, pricing, and location, you can make an informed decision that will enhance your collecting experience. Remember that building a strong relationship with your chosen coin dealer can yield long-term benefits and contribute to the growth and success of your collection.

Classic Rarities Hamburg, NY

classicraritiesClassic Rarities address, phone, website, hours of operation, and more. One of Buffalo’s most respected Coin dealers John has been very active in the hobby for 29 years. He is certified in grading coins by the American Numismatic Association. He attends most major shows across the US, specializing in early U.S. Rare Coins.

Address: 71 Main St Hamburg, NY 14075

Phone: (716) 863-9099

Website: https://classicrarities.com/

Email: drpbst@roadrunner.com

Hours of Operation: Meetings by appointment only

Markham Numismatic Riverside, CA

Markham Numismatic

Markham Numismatic address, phone, website, and more. At Markham Numismatic, we want you to get more cash for your prized possessions. The only way we are able to do this is our unsurpassed knowledge and experience when it comes to your gold, silver and rare coins. Typical scrap gold buying dealers will not know the difference between a highly valuable coin and average coin. To learn more see our section towards the bottom on our homepage “Silver Coins Dealer.” Our goal is to see you come back again as a satisfied customer, having received the most value for your jewelry, gold, coins or diamonds.

People are often confused at our ability to offer the highest value for precious metals. The secret behind our success is simple. Other gold buyers will evaluate your jewelry based only on weight, and from that measurement will pay you approximately one-third of the resale value. Most retailers won’t tell you the actual value of your gold and will sell your items to refineries for extraction. With 25 years experience and grader for the Professional Coin Grading Service (PCGS) and a nationally recognized numismatist, Markham Numismatic is here to give you the most for your precious gold, coins, diamonds, metals and jewelry.

We are the only a coin dealer but a gold buyer that has a global network of resources. We won’t give you pocket change for your jewelry or gold because we have a wider access to precious metal buyers from around the world that our competitors don’t. These buyers specialize in watches, gold coins, silver coins, estate jewelry, diamonds, colored stones, and sterling silver. Because of our connections, we buy the rarest and most unique items for resale to international collectors. As a result, our distributors get more of the products that they want and our customers get more value for their items.


Address: 5225 Canyon Crest Dr, Riverside, CA 92507

Phone: (951) 686-2122

Website: http://www.markhamnumismatics.com

Email: howard92508@yahoo.com

Scotsman Coin & Jewelry Saint Louis, MO

Scotsman Coin & Jewelry

Scotsman Coin & Jewelry address, phone, website, hours of operation, and more. Why is Scotsman able to pay so much for collections? Because of our talented staff’s diverse abilities.


Address: 11262 Olive Blvd, Saint Louis, MO 63141

Phone: (314) 692-2646

Website: http://www.scoins.com


Mon – Fri 8:00 am – 5:00 pm

Sat 8:00 am – 4:00 pm

Sun Closed

Old Pueblo Coin Tucson, AZ

Old Pueblo Coin

Old Pueblo Coin address, phone, website, hours of operation, and more. Old Pueblo Coin was founded in Tucson in 1982 by Rob Weiss and his wife Deb (4th generation Tucsonan). The shop was near Country Club on Speedway for 10 years before the city widened the road. OPC was subsequently located just east of Columbus on Speedway for 20 years. In May of 2012 they relocated to the Northwest corner of Speedway and Columbus.

Old Pueblo Coin buys coins, currency, gold, silver, bullion, silverware, jewelry, and lots of different types of antiques and collectibles. Stop by and look around and find out why Old Pueblo Coin has been Tucson’s Place to Deal for over 30 years.


Address: 4255 E Speedway Blvd, Tucson, AZ 85712

Phone: (520) 881-7200

Website: http://www.oldpueblocoin.com

Email: rob@oldpueblocoin.com


Mon – Fri 9:00 am – 5:30 pm

Sat 9:00 am – 5:00 pm


American Coin & Jewelry Exchange Fort Worth, TX

American Coin & Jewelry Exchange

American Coin & Jewelry Exchange address, phone, website, hours of operation, and more. As one of Fort Worth’s oldest dealers of collector coins and jewelry, we have a large selection of gold, silver and platinum coins and bars.  In addition, we have a large selection of rings, chains, bracelets, necklaces and more.

For more than 27 years, American Coin & Jewelry Exchange has been helping customers and collectors acquire rare coins, precious metals and exquisite jewelry. We sell loose diamonds and have a certified gemologist to assist our customers. American Coin & Jewelry Exchange is a proud member of many industry associations, including ANA (American Numismatic Association), TNA (Texas Numismatic Association), ICTA (Industry Council for Tangible Assets), and CoinNet.


Address: 4955 S Hulen St, Fort Worth, TX 76132

Phone: (817) 717-6665

Website: http://www.americancoinandjewelryexchange.com


Mon – Fri 10:00 am – 6:00 pm

Sat 10:00 am – 3:00 pm

Sun Closed

Gemco Coins Jewelry and Pawn Columbus, OH

Gemco Coins Jewelry and Pawn

Gemco Coins Jewelry and Pawn address, phone, website, hours of operation, and more. Gemco Coins Jewelry and Pawn was founded in 1988 primarily as a coin, paper money, precious metals and jewelry retailer and wholesaler. In December 2012, we applied for and received our pawnbroker license from the Ohio Department of Commerce (State of Ohio License PB.100636.000). Our showroom features collectable coins, coin collector supplies, paper money, estate jewelry and other collectable items in a safe, secure environment.


Address: 5311 W Broad St, Columbus, OH 43228

Phone: (614) 347-1601

Fax: (614) 878-2343

Website: http://www.gemcocoins.com

Lev’s Pawn Columbus, OH

Lev’s Pawn

Lev’s Pawn address, phone, website, hours of operation, and more. We loan the most and pay the most! Lev’s Pawn is locally owned and operated for more than two decades. Lev’s is widely known throughout Central Ohio and Indiana. We have built a reputation on excellent customer service and building lasting relationships with all of our customers.


Address: 216 E Main St, Columbus, OH 43215

Phone: (614) 469-9090

Website: http://www.levspawncolumbusoh.com

Email: levs2@beol.net

Hours: Mon – Sat 9:00 am – 5:30 pm

Mr. Bill’s Collectibles Columbus, OH

Mr. Bill’s Collectibles

Mr. Bill’s Collectibles address, phone, website, hours of operation, and more. We are one of the few collectible stores who will buy it all…we buy Coins, Stamps, Currency, Nascar items, Vintage Sport Cards, Franklin & Danbury Mint Items, Lighters, Pipes, Lladors, Hummels, Some Precious Moments, Jewelry, Sterling Silver flatware & Serving Items, Autographs, Sports Memorabilia, Gold, Platinum, Silver & Gold Bars & Jewelry, Barbie Dolls, Old Toys & Trains, Die Cast Cars, Cookie Jars, Disney Items, Figurines, Star Wars & Star Trek Items, Hallmark Collectibles, Modern Sport Cards that Sell over $20 each or Factory sealed Sets.  We buy Diamonds. Longaberger Baskets. Superman & Spiderman items. Royal Doulton Figurines. Toby Mugs. Collectible watches & Pocketwatches. Some Cameras. Autographed Jerseys, cards, balls, pucks, hats,helmets. Preferably with COA’s.


Address: 4589 E Broad St, Columbus, OH 43213

Phone: (614) 285-3365

Fax: (614) 861-2478

Website: http://www.mrbillscollectibles.com

Email: bill@mrbillscollectibles.com


Mon 11:00 am – 5:00 pm

Tue Closed

Wed 11:00 am – 5:00 pm

Thu Closed

Fri 11:00 am – 5:00 pm

Sun Closed


Gemco Coins Jewelry & Pawn Columbus, OH

Gemco Coins Jewelry & Pawn

Gemco Coins Jewelry & Pawn address, phone, website, hours of operation, and more. Gemco Coins Jewelry and Pawn was founded in 1988 primarily as a coin, paper money, precious metals and jewelry retailer and wholesaler. In December 2012, we applied for and received our pawnbroker license from the Ohio Department of Commerce (State of Ohio License PB.100636.000).

Our showroom features collectable coins, coin collector supplies, paper money, estate jewelry and other collectable items in a safe, secure environment.

We buy, sell and make loans on a variety of other items including electronics, musical instruments, tools, etc.

In addition to our physical location, we have been a member of ebay (gemcocoinsjewelry) since 2000 and have the coveted Top Rated Plus seller rating. Our current 100% Positive Feedback rating is evidence of our commitment to customer service, fair pricing and striving for excellence on all transactions regardless of dollar amount. As of this writing, we have over 15000 ebay transactions and thousands of satisfied customers throughout the United States.

Our current staff has over 60 plus years combined of numismatic experience. We also provide written insurance and estate appraisals.


Address: 5311 W Broad St, Columbus, OH 43228

Phone: (614) 347-1601

Fax:  (614) 878-2643

Email: gemcocoin@sbcglobal.net